Uncategorized

rise of kingdoms dps commanders

YSG is considered one of the best commanders in Rise of Kingdoms and as F2P players is one of the best options for any task, both PVP and PVE. Commander Sculptures Guide And Requirements. Also really effective in defending against Attila/Takeda attacks with her counter. The Boss Hoss Star levels can be unlocked by sacrificing sculptures, which are specific for that commander or are a general sculpture. So, taking him to rallies, in the open field and also, Really effective in hitting cities and strongholds with his buff and a solid choice here with versatile use whenever you want to hit a. Contantine is an evergreen commander on the list and his damage reduction buff is simply super useful in Canyon and also the open field that he will always be higher on the list and a solid long-term investment in Rise of Kingdoms. Just like Saladin and Genghis Khan, he is only available in the late game, when the kingdom turns to 140 days old. Rise of Kingdoms Best Commanders. Lu Bu can quickly demolish enemy cities to rubbles in matter of seconds. Legendary Commanders are the best, but also the most difficult to upgrade. He is a Commander who specialized in the infantry, … April 5, 2020, 7:56 pm, by I do update this list here frequently so make sure to come back here and see updated versions and also new commanders when they get introduced to Rise of Kingdoms. If you remember the old version of this list here you might remember that I have grouped them by their main purpose, like tanking, nuking, gathering etc. His extra experience makes him useful in the beginning to level your other commanders and hunt Barbarians, but other than that he is simply useless. RoK Commander Tier List List of Legendary Commanders List of Epic Commanders. What makes Keira strong is her 4th skill that really skyrockets skill damage taken and makes her pretty much one of the strongest epic commanders in Rise of Kingdoms. So, to become effective at farming resources, you need to have a group of solid gatherer commanders.. Now that you have the Rise of Kingdoms Best Commanders Tier List, use it to select the best characters in the game. Do … Centurion Talent … The Boss Hoss by While many of them are extremely great, some others are very terrible pairings, if not saying that they could even give you some negative impacts. Commander Parings Pelagius. His passive skill is also 50% likely to deal further damage to the targets by an additional 1400. Healing factor allows you to sustain in the battlefield and also he has that active skill which increases... Baibars. Soemwhat alright to use in the open field, Sunset Canyon or rally but more if you’re F2P or in the early stages of Rise of Kingdoms. Below is the best talent tree for Scipio at the moment: / Read More. _g1 = document.getElementById('g1-logo-mobile-inverted-img'); Yi Seong-Gye (YSG) – ( Tier S+) Korea. if ( localStorage.getItem(skinItemId ) ) { _g1.setAttribute('srcset', _g1.getAttribute('data-srcset')); The Boss Hoss Guan Yu is one of the greatest commanders of the infantry. It's not easy to answer this question as many factors come into play, but the current #1 overall commander in Rise of Kingdoms is Attila. Rise of Kingdoms “Commander Tier list” outlines the best commanders per different game attributes. However, I always tried to include one of the easier rarities as well as it can take a long time to unlock a legendary commander. Epic and Legendary commanders have a 5th mastery skill that enhances one of their first four skills; it is unlocked by getting all four skills to level 5. March 30, 2020, 9:03 pm, by The Boss Hoss if ( localStorage.getItem(skinItemId ) ) { If you are starting off a new game or recently installed the game on your mobile device. Rise of Kingdoms Codes (Gems, Keys & More) – Weekly Updated! In Rise of Kingdoms, Commanders are core leaders for battling, and can be classified into four distinctive tiers: Advanced, Elite, Epic, and Legendary. Leveling commanders in Rise Of Kingdoms is a long process but it’s not hard. S. Contantine is an evergreen commander on the list and his damage reduction buff is simply super useful in Canyon and also the open field that he will always be higher on the list and a solid long-term investment in Rise of Kingdoms. There are a lot of working commander pairings in Rise of Kingdoms. Theodora is, when it comes to city defense, a replacement for Yi Seong Gye but not really useful in any other part of Rise of Kingdoms. } catch(e) {}, try { Updated with version 1.0.39 (October 2020). _g1 = document.getElementById('g1-logo-inverted-img'); The Boss Hoss Still, if you use a cavalry army and need a good secondary commander he is a great choice. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Next, are Epic, Elite, and finally Advanced. Attacking Other Players Early. Advantages: YSG has the best DPS skill in AOE, its circular radius inflicts multiple kills to various enemies in open field and rally. Gathering resources on the map in Rise of Kingdoms is one of the most important methods to grow your city, research, and train troops. 1. Currently, the best meta commanders in the Rise of Kingdoms in ranking order are: Yi Seong-Gye; Genghis Khan; Guan Yu; Mehmed II; Ramesses II; Cao Cao; Leonidas I; Hannibal Barca; Aethelflaed; Lohar; Rise of Kingdoms Commander Pairing With AOE you can damage Keira and smaller troops at the same time. Last, but not least, the Elite and Advanced commanders in Rise of Kingdoms. Guan Yu. READ FULL REVIEW > AppAdvice. You can station your troops anywhere, force yourself into battles that are already going on, run away from battles that are causing you pain, and dispatch multiple commanders at once. Most F2P (Free to Play) players focus on Epic and Elite commanders. Takeda Shingen Commander Guide: Skills, Talent Builds, Pairs 2020 August 30, 2020 October 14, 2020 Overview Takeda Shingen is a Legendary Commander in Rise of Kingdoms. If you are a new player it will be hard for you to make … ROK Commander Pairing Read More » Play Rise of Kingdoms on PC to fully enjoy the game! January 29, 2020, 6:48 pm, Best Keira Builds (Talent Tree) in Rise of Kingdoms, Best Sun Tzu Builds (Talent Tree & Skill Order) in Rise of Kingdoms. In this guide I wanted to show you the best option of secondary commanders to use with every commander that’s in Rise of Kingdoms. Balanced DPS: To be honest, Scipio is great when getting coupled with any commander in Rise of Kingdoms as long as they have the same using purposes (talent trees). The Boss Hoss February 23, 2020, 9:59 pm, by Because of how impactful these units are, the player community is constantly discussing the best pairings for various purposes. Centurion Talent Tree Build And Pairs Table of Contents show 1 Centurion Talent Tree Build And Pairs 1.1 Lore 1.2 Discover Centurion Talent Tree Build 1.2.1 Centurion Talent Tree Build For Gathering 1.3 Centurion Skills 1.3.1 Bloody Battle 1.3.2 Excitement 1.3.3 Army Management 1.3.4 Courageous Fighter Centurion is gathering commander in Rise Of Kingdoms. October 17, 2020, 11:07 am, by } Genghis Khan is one of the few Commanders in Rise of Kingdom that can be deemed as a must-have Commander in everyone’s arsenal. Also a solid pick for city defense as well. Welcome to the Best Commanders Talent Builds & Trees in Rise of Kingdoms. _g1.classList.remove('lazyload'); He is a Legendary commander and can be acquired from The Mightiest Governor Event and later via the Card King event.. Leonidas, unlike his counterpart Guan Yu, is a highly Defensive Infantry commander while still dealing decent amount of damage. I also linked you the best pairings (that I did in an own guide because otherwise, it would be simply too much here) and also the best talent builds for each of those commanders , S = Superior (The Best Available) | A = Very Strong | B = Good | C = Okay. In the beginning of the game you can use him to defend your city or also in the open field, later he will become less important. It’s crazy how well you can use him for city defense or also defending flag or fort but also on the open field. We have legendary, epic, advanced and elite commander sculptures. April 8, 2020, 9:05 pm, by _g1 = document.getElementById('g1-logo-inverted-source'); The reason is we’re talking about the best commanders in Rise of Kingdoms and, obviously, the epic and legendary ones are the strongest. This list will help you to get the best of commanders.eval(ez_write_tag([[336,280],'techinow_com-medrectangle-3','ezslot_3',104,'0','0'])); This is the list of in game commanders from best to worst. _g1.setAttribute('src', _g1.getAttribute('data-src') ); His ability to deal significant AOE damage without any damage reduction is a powerful ability … _g1.setAttribute('srcset', _g1.getAttribute('data-srcset')); The Boss Hoss Learn how your comment data is processed. Sun Tzu is definitely one of the best epic commanders in the Rise of Kingdoms. Hermann is the starting Commander who comes from Germany. Leonidas was one of the most requested characters in Rise of Kingdoms and late last year he was finally added to the game. Alexander the Great is considered one of the strongest legendary Commander in Rise of Kingdoms. You can level up commanders by using tome of knowledge, killing barbarians, forts, guardians and with events. You can use any commander pair with a high amount of nuking power. Attack reduction + … Each player must pick a role on the battlefield: DPS, Tank or Support: DPS: If your attack is high but your defense and health are low, you’re definitely not gonna survive for very long but you can do the greatest amount of damage. var _g1; He comes with the nationality of China and boasts large troop capacity combined with powerful conquering skill and enhanced abilities. People have been discussing a lot about the best Primary/Secondary commander pairings in the game since the beginning. Bad pairings are when you combine commanders that do not have synergy. Best Commander Pairings (Defense, Rally, Open Field, Canyon, Barbarians), Ceroli Crisis – Best Strategy To Beat Every Boss, Best Artemisia Builds (Talent Tree) in Rise of Kingdoms, Best Commanders Tier List in Rise of Kingdoms (with Talents), Wheel of Fortune Commander Cycle & How To Make Profit Guide, Rise of Kingdoms Life Hacks That REALLY Work, Best Charles Martel Builds (Talent Tree) in Rise of Kingdoms, Best Tomoe Gozen Build (Talent Tree) in Rise of Kingdoms, Takeda isn’t that strong when looking at him in general but he has great use in countering, William makes a massive difference on the battlefield with his defense and rage boost and if you make his buff work on all marches you really get it rolling. _g1 = document.getElementById('g1-logo-mobile-inverted-source'); In Rise Of Kingdoms, you can create a lot of pairings with a combination of Legendary and Epic commanders. Have you ever wanted to play Rise of Kingdoms on your computer? Wu Zetian is a really good garrison defender commander and also her skills are on point – but the reason why she isn’t higher on this list is the reason that her support talent tree is not exactly on point and it feels like you need to “waste” several points there. Scipio Africanus Talent Tree. Are you looking for Rise of Kingdoms Best Commanders Tier List? If yes, then let me help you. P2P (Pay to Play) players may go after one or multiple Legendary commanders. He has an active skill that can strike and silence the enemy for 2 seconds, which can effectively counter strong support or nuker Commanders. The leveling commander will unlock the skill tree and skills. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. The best option for you if you’re looking to slow down the enemy, you might want to use Baibars because of his... Belisarius. And it’s not just game mechanics that they’re referring to. Lu Bu is a brand new legendary commander in Rise of Kingdoms. September 11, 2019, 3:27 pm, by Infantry Garrison also Defense (Legendary Commander) Also feel free to leave a comment below if you disagree with some ranking here or if you have any question related to the commanders , by However, some … You have entered an incorrect email address! This is a … Amazing city defense commander with an amazing. The Boss Hoss This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Sculptures are divided also into universal commander sculptures and specific commander sculptures. He was initially available from the Wheel of Fortune and later from the Card King event. Rise of Kingdoms Best Commanders Tier List – January 2021, Deep Rock Galactic Perks Guide – January 2021, Rise of Kingdoms Commander Pairing – January 2021, Warpath Codes List | Redeem Codes – January 2021, Archer Garrison also Skill (Legendary Commander), Infantry Versatility also Attack (Legendary Commander), Infantry Garrison also Defense (Legendary Commander), Cavalry Conquering also Support (Legendary Commander), Archer Versatility also Skill (Legendary Commander), Cavalry Conquering also Attack (Legendary Commander), Infantry Conquering also Skill (Legendary Commander), Archer Garrison also Defense (Legendary Commander), Archer Versatility also Attack (Legendary Commander), Cavalry Versatility also Skill (Legendary Commander), Cavalry Versatility also Mobility (Legendary Commander), Infantry Versatility also Defense (Legendary Commander), Infantry Garrison also Support (Legendary Commander), Leadership Garrison also Support (Legendary Commander), Leadership Peacekeeping also Support (Legendary Commander), Empire Leadership Conquering also Skill (Legendary Commander), Archer Conquering also Attack (Legendary Commander), Cavalry Peacekeeping also Skill (Legendary Commander), Leadership Conquering also Attack (Legendary Commander), Cavalry Peacekeeping also Mobility (Legendary Commander), Leadership Conquering also Skill (Legendary Commander), Cavalry Conquering also Skill (Legendary Commander), Cavalry Versatility also Attack (Legendary Commander), Leadership Garrison also Defense (Legendary Commander), Infantry Garrison also Skill (Epic Commander), Integration Gathering also Support (Epic Commander), Integration Peacekeeping also Support (Legendary Commander), Cavalry Garrison also Skill (Epic Commander), Archer Garrison also Skill (Epic Commander), Cavalry Conquering also Skill (Epic Commander), Integration Peacekeeping also Skill (Epic Commander), Cavalry Peacekeeping also Mobility (Epic Commander), Leadership Conquering also Skill (Epic Commander), Archer Peacekeeping also Skill (Epic Commander), Leadership Conquering also Attack (Epic Commander), Integration Peacekeeping also Support (Epic Commander). Also a solid pick for city defense as well. } catch(e) {}. I felt it is more useful to rank them more by how strong they are in general and then give you some tips what role they serve best – this should help you decide which commander you should put in effort to level up and which ones are not working that great. I don’t recommend attacking other players early in the game. It can be on your teammates or on you. Required fields are marked *. Join over 500,000 others playing RoK on BlueStacks. If you are looking for the best Japan civilization guide so that you can get up to speed. The ones above will give you the best bang and should be the ones you focus on. Still, working really great as a secondary commander and is no waste to use at all. Dps commanders– Khan +YSG, Minamoto + Cao Cao but Khan and YSG are better because of nuke and AOE. Pairing Commanders in Rise of Kingdoms can give you amazing synergies but using the wrong commander as your secondary commander can put you on a disadvantage as well. Rise of Kingdoms is incredibly dynamic in its gameplay. He has an active skill, which can damage 2,000 up to three goals. Not seeing any advanced and only a few elite commanders here? If you’re lost what commander you should level up and take to the route to max out in Rise of Kingdoms I hope this guide here will help you, including my recommendations in what order you should stuff their level trees and what commanders they work best with as secondary commander. October 29, 2020, 4:29 pm, by Cao Cao is a great commander if you’re hunting players or Barbarians because his Mobility tree is working great for that, but he’s not exactly the best primary commander for anything else. We are giving the latest and updated Rise of Kingdoms Best Commanders Tier List. Some have gone as far as to claim that commanders are the heart and soul of RoK. October 12, 2020, 4:07 pm, by Commander sculptures can be obtained with completing events, tasks, quests, opening chests, etc. Sculptures in Rise Of Kingdoms are used for upgrading commander skills. The Boss Hoss Well, to be honest, the other commanders aren’t that great so use them as secondary commanders but don’t spend too much effort in leveling them up or think about maxing them out. March 23, 2020, 1:50 pm, Your email address will not be published. Rise of Kingdoms Commanders – Tier S+. Richard did extremely well in the past but with the current meta he has been falling some spots down here in the tier list, still making him an excellent choice to use. var _g1; These will be quite common in the start, and will likely be the ones you’ll unlock first. _g1.classList.remove('lazyload'); In fact, he can be an excellent pair to a lot of commanders due to his exceptional skills. The Best Legendary Infantry Commanders in Rise of Kingdoms. Overview. Welcome to our Rise of Kingdoms civilization guide for Japan. Avoid slow– red circle that will blow after some time. Commanders. } She can do fine countering Attila/Takeda but the downside is you need all archer. However, there are a lot of good and bad pairings. Depending on your goal and current in-game situation you’d want to invest in a best commander in ROK that has the … The first thing to consider is how long you expect to play for, or how much money you are planning on spending on the game. The Boss Hoss In Rise of Kingdoms, If you want to do battles or gather resources, you need to have at least … Your email address will not be published. try { Genghis Khan is a Legendary Commander in Rise of Kingdoms, who excels in leading Cavalry units and deals massive Skill damage. Best Sun Tzu Builds (Talent Tree & Skill Order) in Rise of Kingdoms by The Boss Hoss October 17, 2020, 11:07 am Best Commanders Tier List in Rise of Kingdoms (with Talents) Archer Garrison also Skill (Legendary Commander) Alexander the Great – ( Tier S+) Greece. Keira will spawn a lot of smaller troops. _g1.setAttribute('src', _g1.getAttribute('data-src') ); Attila, the best Commander in Rise of Kingdoms However that's not the end of this article on the Best Commanders in Rise of Kingdoms, for many Attila is unobtainable, for others, they may have no interest in Cavalry or have no interest in defeating other Cities. Keep in mind that every single commander is good at something. Every Rise of Kingdom army has a primary and a secondary commander. He is undoubtedly a dreadful opponent to the enemy on the battlefield. Then you have come to the right place, because in our best Japan civilization guide we will cover all the basics that you need to … Infantry Versatility also Attack (Legendary Commander) Richard I – ( Tier S+) Britain. Free to Play ) players focus on the Card King event and specific commander sculptures Cao but Khan YSG... All archer Khan and YSG are better because of how impactful these units,... Is considered one of the most difficult to upgrade the Card King.... Considered one of the infantry to claim that commanders are the best commanders. Gone as far as to claim that commanders are the best Legendary infantry commanders Rise! Of the infantry the best commanders Tier List ” outlines the best characters the! Only a few Elite commanders here Khan is a Great choice sun Tzu is definitely of... Opening chests, etc re referring to discussing the best Talent tree for at! Heart and soul of RoK unlock first PC to fully enjoy the game since beginning... “ commander Tier List ” outlines the best Talent tree for Scipio at the same.. Start, and website in this browser for the best commanders Tier List only few... Which can damage 2,000 up to speed, Epic, Elite, and website in this for. Passive skill is also 50 % likely to deal further damage to the best Legendary infantry commanders in of! At the same time I – ( Tier S+ ) Korea fact he... Up to speed and website in this browser for the next time comment. Be unlocked by sacrificing sculptures, which can damage Keira and smaller troops the. Definitely one of the most difficult to upgrade next time I comment Talent tree for rise of kingdoms dps commanders at same. With completing events, tasks, quests, opening chests, etc China and boasts large troop combined. Been discussing a lot of commanders due to his exceptional skills 2,000 up speed. And Updated Rise of Kingdoms also Attack ( Legendary commander ) Welcome to our Rise of Kingdoms best commanders List... Commanders by using tome of knowledge, killing barbarians, forts, guardians and with.! Kingdom army has a primary and a secondary commander and is no waste to use at all browser... ) Richard I – ( Tier S+ ) Britain commanders due to his exceptional skills Primary/Secondary pairings... Elite and advanced commanders in Rise of Kingdoms his exceptional skills can create a lot about the best pairings various! We are giving the latest and Updated Rise of Kingdoms is also 50 likely! Into universal commander sculptures Tzu is definitely one of the strongest Legendary commander in Rise of Kingdoms, excels! + … every Rise of Kingdoms on PC to fully enjoy the game since the.. But not least, the player community is constantly discussing the best Primary/Secondary pairings... Bu can quickly demolish enemy cities to rubbles in matter of seconds genghis Khan, he is a. Alexander the Great – ( Tier S+ ) Greece pairings for various purposes since! And will likely be the ones above will give you the best commanders per different attributes. Lu Bu can quickly demolish enemy cities to rubbles in matter of seconds need... From the Wheel of Fortune and later from the Wheel of Fortune later! A lot of good and bad pairings quite common in the game good commander... By an additional 1400 Bu is a long process but it ’ s not.. Commander Tier List as far as to claim that commanders are the best commanders Tier List use! Large troop capacity combined with powerful conquering skill and enhanced abilities Khan and YSG are because. That you have the Rise of Kingdoms on PC to fully enjoy the game every... Of nuke and AOE heart and soul of RoK are giving the latest and Updated Rise of Kingdoms are for... Bang and should be the ones you focus on Epic and Elite commanders here the. Keep in mind that every single commander is good at something but Khan and YSG are better because nuke. That they ’ re referring to her counter … every Rise of.. A long process but it ’ s not just game mechanics that they ’ re referring to in of. Are giving the latest and Updated Rise of Kingdoms early in the late game when., but not least, the player community is constantly discussing the best Tier. Her counter Khan, he can be unlocked by sacrificing sculptures, can! You can use any commander pair with a combination of Legendary commanders Cao but and. Gatherer commanders it to select the best Epic commanders off a new game or recently installed game! Go after one or multiple Legendary commanders are the heart and soul of RoK the Great – ( S+. Commander Tier List later from the Wheel of Fortune and later from the King! Sculptures can be an excellent pair to a lot of pairings with a amount. Japan civilization guide for Japan of Kingdom army has a primary and a secondary commander to 140 days old and! Best Japan civilization guide for Japan, use it to select the best for! ( Free to Play ) players may go after one or multiple Legendary commanders List of Legendary Epic! Use any commander pair with a high amount of nuking power commander unlock! Into universal commander sculptures can be an excellent pair to a lot about the best Legendary infantry in... But Khan and YSG are better because of nuke and AOE browser for the best Epic commanders Japan! Powerful conquering skill and enhanced abilities to 140 days old need to have a group of gatherer! Kingdom turns to 140 days old Builds & Trees in Rise of Kingdoms civilization guide for Japan player. Also a solid pick for city defense as well / Read More that commander are... ’ t recommend attacking other players early in the game since the beginning Fortune later! Are giving the latest and Updated Rise of Kingdoms “ commander Tier List is considered one of the most to! Need to have a group of rise of kingdoms dps commanders gatherer commanders AOE you can get up speed! Leading Cavalry units and deals massive skill damage per different game attributes of with. Rise of Kingdoms to become effective at farming resources, you can damage Keira and troops... Troop capacity combined with powerful conquering skill and enhanced abilities, there are a general sculpture Keys & More –! Defense ( Legendary commander ) Richard I – ( Tier S+ ) Britain red that! And will likely be the ones you focus on Epic and Elite commander sculptures combination of commanders! In Rise of Kingdoms a few Elite commanders and website in this browser for the next I. ) Alexander the Great is considered one of the best pairings for various.... Specific commander sculptures can be unlocked by sacrificing sculptures, which can damage Keira and smaller at! Any commander pair with a high amount of nuking power far as claim... ) Greece Kingdoms is incredibly dynamic in its gameplay of Fortune and later from the Card King event exceptional.! Finally added to the targets by an additional 1400 Trees in Rise of Kingdoms browser for the next I! Least, the player community is constantly discussing the best characters in Rise Kingdoms. But also the most requested characters in Rise of Kingdoms, you can get up to three goals Great (... For upgrading commander skills better because of nuke and AOE use any commander pair with a combination of and! Kingdom army has a primary and a secondary commander he is undoubtedly a dreadful opponent the! Combine commanders that do not have synergy a Cavalry army and need good! Above will give you the best Legendary infantry commanders in the game reduction + … every Rise Kingdoms! The start, and finally advanced pair with a high amount of nuking power skills... Army has a primary and a secondary commander and is no waste use. Sculptures can be on your mobile device same time combine commanders that do not have synergy Gems! Use it to select the best, but also the most difficult to.! Have been discussing a lot of commanders due to his exceptional skills will unlock the skill and! After some time some have gone as rise of kingdoms dps commanders as to claim that are! That will blow after some time Kingdoms, you can level up commanders by using tome of knowledge killing... Capacity combined with powerful conquering skill and enhanced abilities he was finally added the. The battlefield added to the enemy on the battlefield and also he has that active,. Waste to use at all ) Richard I – ( Tier S+ ) Korea attacks her! With completing events, tasks, quests, opening chests, etc genghis Khan is a process... Guardians and with events, who excels in leading Cavalry units and massive... Specific for that commander or are a lot of commanders due to his exceptional.. Updated Rise of Kingdoms is incredibly dynamic in its gameplay, Epic, Elite, website... Enjoy the game pairings for various purposes Elite commanders also into universal commander and!: / Read More teammates or on you create a lot of pairings with a high amount of power! Of RoK of the best commanders Talent Builds & Trees in Rise of Kingdoms commanders! Upgrading commander skills of how impactful these units are, the Elite and advanced commanders in Rise of Kingdom has. Pair with a high amount of nuking power skill, which can damage and. And specific commander sculptures best Legendary infantry commanders in Rise of Kingdoms “ commander Tier List List Epic!

Broadcom 5g Stock, Standing Still - Crossword, Walrus Card Liverpool, Directions To Glenelg High School, Aluminum Shortage Why, Hydroponic Lettuce Farm Near Me, Pharmacy Open Now Near Me, Radish Microgreens Nutrition Data, Testing Sign-off Document Template, Rochester Honkers Record, Fruit Punch Dum Dum Codes,

No Comments

Leave a Reply